On the last day of 2025, the Massachusetts Appeals Court reminded employers about the value of a self-audit. This case is the first to apply the “affirmative defense” under the Massachusetts Equal Pay Act (MEPA) since it was enacted in 2018. Instead of allowing fact-intensive, complicated litigation under an employee’s equal pay claim, the defendant employer was able to assert the MEPA affirmative defense:
- That they had conducted a self-evaluation within three years of the date the complaint was filed;
- That the self-evaluation was done in good faith; and
- That the employer had made progress in eliminating pay disparities.
You may recall this case at the Superior Court level because it was a state agency that was being sued. In a delicious twist, it is the Massachusetts Office of the Attorney General who made the successful argument that a proper self evaluation and reasonable progress towards equity can be a full defense against equal pay claims, even if disparities initially existed. No cap as the kids say.
We were early proponents of how useful a self-audit is for an affirmative defense and developed a fixed fee service, which has helped so many employers. If the self-audit worked for the AG, it will certainly work for you. And if you have done a self-audit in the past, make sure it is updated every three years to be a valid defense.
We can help. Contact us or check out our MEPA audit service.
Discover more from Foley & Foley, PC
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


